Hardback or paperback? hardback
Synopsis Samantha, a popular girl, is killed in a car accident--and then relives the last day of her life 7 times.
Evaluation Beautiful writing and definitely thought-provoking.
Universal Themes death, friendship, love, responsibility
Edginess Factor Teen drinking, smoking, drug use, and sex, plus language.
Bonus Factors Should make teens think about how their actions affect others, and how thoughtless cruelty is still cruelty. Raises some class issues. While the anti-bullying message is pretty clear, it's drawn in shades of grey, allowing characters to be complex.
Anti-Bonus Factors All main characters are white. In fact, all minor characters are white, too.
Will They Like It? Girls will; I doubt guys would. It's a fast and fascinating read, and it's very interesting watching how Samantha's altered actions on each of the seven days change--or don't change--the people around her.
Recommendation Not suitable for age group. I think this would be a terrific choice for book clubs for older kids--maybe 10th grade.
Tuesday, January 4, 2011
Monday, January 3, 2011
For the Win by Cory Doctorow
Hardback or Paperback Hardback
Synopsis You should probably go read this Wikipedia article on MMORPGs (just the intro and the section on economics will be enough). OK. With that background, Doctorow has posited a plausible sweatshop of the near future: third world teenagers "mining" MMORPG worlds for specialized items that first world players will pay for on the black market. The book's conflict centers around those workers' attempt to unionize.
Evaluation This is a book about ideas and social action as much as it is about story. Sure, it's about online gaming and suspense and running from the bad guys, but it's also about politics, unions, economics, and social justice. Doctorow has to do several information dumps (particularly about economics), and he tries to do it gracefully. I found it interesting...but I'm not fourteen. In spite of those sections, it's a fast-paced and suspenseful book, with danger that feels genuine and a message that resonates.
Universal Themes social justice, bravery, standing up to tyranny
Edginess Language (although no f-bombs that I recall) and LOTS of graphic violence. Lots of smoking.
Bonus Factors References to the history of unions, plus lots of information about economics and politics; although the author is white, the cast (and setting) is international; deals with issues of poverty, class, and social justice.
Anti-bonus factors None, really.
Will they like it? I'm honestly not sure. It's long, and there are those information dumps--and understanding the denouement really requires understanding at least most of what he says about investment & trading. But there are also a lot of compelling characters, plenty of action, and suspense galore. It also has that "teenagers against the world" vibe (which is probably what makes it YA vs. adult fiction). I certainly found it compelling
Recommendation I think it's a definite after it comes out in paperback. Maybe even now, because of the ties to the social studies curriculum. (How many books do you find that tie in to civics and economics??)
Synopsis You should probably go read this Wikipedia article on MMORPGs (just the intro and the section on economics will be enough). OK. With that background, Doctorow has posited a plausible sweatshop of the near future: third world teenagers "mining" MMORPG worlds for specialized items that first world players will pay for on the black market. The book's conflict centers around those workers' attempt to unionize.
Evaluation This is a book about ideas and social action as much as it is about story. Sure, it's about online gaming and suspense and running from the bad guys, but it's also about politics, unions, economics, and social justice. Doctorow has to do several information dumps (particularly about economics), and he tries to do it gracefully. I found it interesting...but I'm not fourteen. In spite of those sections, it's a fast-paced and suspenseful book, with danger that feels genuine and a message that resonates.
Universal Themes social justice, bravery, standing up to tyranny
Edginess Language (although no f-bombs that I recall) and LOTS of graphic violence. Lots of smoking.
Bonus Factors References to the history of unions, plus lots of information about economics and politics; although the author is white, the cast (and setting) is international; deals with issues of poverty, class, and social justice.
Anti-bonus factors None, really.
Will they like it? I'm honestly not sure. It's long, and there are those information dumps--and understanding the denouement really requires understanding at least most of what he says about investment & trading. But there are also a lot of compelling characters, plenty of action, and suspense galore. It also has that "teenagers against the world" vibe (which is probably what makes it YA vs. adult fiction). I certainly found it compelling
Recommendation I think it's a definite after it comes out in paperback. Maybe even now, because of the ties to the social studies curriculum. (How many books do you find that tie in to civics and economics??)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)